The Vectra X3 3-dimensional face scanner allows us to visualise the erythema of superficial layers of skin in addition to its regular scanning functions. The aim of our study was to find out whether changes we provoked in the circulation of the skin would be registered and displayed by the face scanner. We measured the circulation in the skin of the cheeks of 20 volunteers with a face scanner, a laser Doppler device, and a skin pigmentation analyser before and after the application of a nitric oxide cream. The results were compared in terms of grey tones, local concentrations of haemoglobin, and erythema. All methods showed significant changes (p < 0.001) before and after application of the cream. The study proved that the Vectra X3 recognises changes in skin circulation and displays them in a simple and evident way.
Over the last few years, 3-dimensional face scanners have become a popular device and an important component in daily clinical routines, alongside tools that monitor skin perfusion.
To improve clinical routines, devices that combine diverse functions are needed. A device that is supposed to fulfil these requirements is the Vectra X3 3D face scanner (Canfield Scientific Incorporated, Fairfield, NJ, USA). The scanner contains RapidBuilder Multimedia Simulation Format (XStream Software) (RBX), which enables the operator to visualise melanin and erythema in the skin. This means that the operator can see abnormal concentrations of melanin, such as hyperpigmentation, or vascular irregularities, such as telangiectasia.
The primary aim of this study was to evaluate the scanner’s erythema function, by comparing the results of the face scanner with a laser Doppler device and a skin pigmentation analyser.
Material and methods
After institutional approval and with informed consent, 20 volunteers (mean (SD) age 24 (1.5) years, 13 women, 7 men) participated in this clinical study. The exclusion criterion was an acute or chronic disease of the facial skin. Three-dimensional scans of their faces were taken using the Vectra X3. On a selected portion of the skin, we measured the relative concentration of haemoglobin with the laser Doppler O2C (LEA Medizintechnik GmbH, Gießen, Germany). The concentrations of melanin and erythema was measured with the skin pigmentation analyser (Courage + Khazaka Electronic GmbH, Cologne, Germany). Both devices sent light of specific wavelengths into the skin and analysed the light that was reflected. Then, we used the nitric oxide cream to increase local blood flow to the selected area, as described by Opländer et al, and we repeated all three measurements immediately.
For the homogeneous and detailed analysis of the face scans, the colours red and brown were filtered, which corresponded to the distribution of haemoglobin and melanin. Then the scans were transformed into grey pictures. On the selected area, four corresponding points were identified, the grey tones were measured and mean values calculated ( Fig. 1 ).
The data obtained were structured using MS Office Excel 2003 ® (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA, USA). Statistical analyses were done with the help of SAS ® (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA). The Pearson correlation coefficient was used to investigate any significant changes in measurement for each person. A paired t -test was used to compare the three methods of measuring the circulation of the skin. All data were expressed as mean (SD), and values of p = ≤0.05 were considered to be significant.
After the cream was applied to the skin, macroscopic changes in colour were detected. After the facial scans were converted into a 2-dimensional picture and grey tones, the mean measured grey tone was 163.3 RGB before the application of the cream and 99.9 RGB afterwards, which corresponds to a darker grey tone. All devices showed a significant improvement in local blood flow after the cream was applied (p < 0.001) ( Table 1 ).
|Vectra X3||Grey||163 (23)||100 (29)||<0.001|
|SPA 99||Erythema||51 (10)||58 (9)||<0.001|
|O2C||Local haemoglobin||64 (8)||77 (6)||<0.001|
|O2C||Velocity||15 (6)||11 (4)||<0.001|
|O2C||Flow||53 (36)||168 (61)||<0.001|
The Pearson correlation coefficient showed a strongly positive linear relationship of the grey tone and the local concentration of haemoglobin, (r = 0.772) the erythema and the local concentration of haemoglobin, (r = 0.764) and erythema and the grey tone (r = 0.796). All results were significant (p < 0.0001).
According to these results, the haemoglobin concentration values were assigned to corresponding grey tones in a chart ( Fig. 2 ).
The Vectra X3 camera has been used in many studies and it has been proved that the scans are particularly useful for documentation, anthropometric, and volume measurements. Using the RBX technology our measurement showed that the 3-dimensional camera shows changes of blood flow in the superficial skin layer with great sensitivity.
For daily use, a colour scale with a corresponding chart was developed. By using the colour scale, it is possible to assess the local haemoglobin concentration by the RGB value of a picture. Although the developed procedure provides a reliable output, the system can be further optimised as not all grey tones were covered in this study. The scale could be particularly useful to evaluate areas of skin with scars from previous operations or burns, and to evaluate critical areas of perfusion when further operations with flap rotations have to be planned.